Recap – Burn Notice 4.12: “Guilty As Charged”

Jesse Porter is pissed. John Barrett is not a very nice guy and he’s brought an army. Vaughn is probably a little cranky too. All of these guys are looking for Michael Westen, and not to give him a hug. What a way to cap the first half of a great fourth season of Burn Notice!

In case you weren’t one of the people (myself included) who were watching USA’s handy marathon of the season to date today, here’s the quick 411: Michael has his hands on Simon’s (Garret Dillahunt) Bible, which decodes…something important. It’s the key to bringing down the very bad people that both Vaughn (Robert Wisdom) and Jesse (Coby Bell) have been looking for over the last few years. These very bad people have come to Miami in the person of John Barrett (Robert Patrick), who wants the Bible to take down Vaughn and ostensibly continue his global reign of mayhem. And did I mention that Jesse discovered it was Michael who burned him, and seems ready to fulfill his early-season vow to make whomever burned him pay, friend or not? Even Michael’s mom, Maddie (Emmy nominee Sharon Gless), is upset with him. It’s probably the worst time to be Michael Westen. We know that he’s going to make it through this alive (unless Jeffrey Donovan decides to retire from acting a la Amanda Bynes), but that doesn’t mean his life can’t be totally wrecked…again.

We ended the last episode with one of the most chilling scenes ever seen on this show, and we pick up not long after. Though Maddie and Fiona are worried about Jesse (Maddie: “Jesse and I were friends. Maybe I’ll stay and try to convince him not to shoot you”), Michael knows he has to focus on Barrett and his incoming army, lest Jesse get burned for nothing and, of course, global mayhem continues. The team has tracked down Barrett’s compound and pops in for a visit. Robert Patrick continues to play something close to his Tom Ryan character from The Unit: a raging jackass in authority, though this time not government authority. Michael sets up a meeting with Barrett, wanting to know what it is the Bible actually decodes before he goes handing it over to anyone.

Vaughn thinks Michael is the coolest thing since sliced bread for this. He’s also heard about Jesse investigating his own burning, and complains about it too. Michael basically tells him that he’s going to do things his own way, which is to take Barrett and not turn him over to Vaughn, but to whomever they need to in order to set things right. In the middle of the gang’s little “what do we do” conversation, a guy working for high-priced defense attorney named Scott (played by Cold Case‘s Danny Pino, who’s about unrecognizable with the beard) comes to see them. Scott’s daughter has been kidnapped, which means Team Burn Notice has a new case at the same time the world is falling in. When it rains, it pours. Scott knows exactly who did it: the brother one of his clients, as leverage to get Scott to win his trial, which is of course impossible to win. Said brother is named Dale, and he is played by Michael Rooker. I’ve never been that impressed by Rooker (and in a bit of trivia, also co-starred with Robert Patrick in a little movie called Rogue Force in 1996), but let’s face it, he’s not the bad guy we’re all worried about this week.

Fiona and Sam are back to arguing with each other in the process of helping Michael when they spot Jesse watching them bicker. He’s obviously not following them, because he’s not even trying to avoid being caught. However, before she can get to Jesse, he’s already taken off. Fiona decides she’s going to try and find Jesse to hopefully keep him from blowing Michael’s head off. This leaves Sam and Michael to come up with a plan, which involves borrowing a sub from drug cartels to try and make a water approach to the bad guy HQ. Well, that’s a new one.

Michael meets with Vaughn again to go over the plan, which of course, Vaughn does not like. However, Michael is able to get Jesse’s location – at a hotel, under a fake name – from Vaughn and decides to go after him before Vaughn’s people do. This is considerate and good of him, but then the show chooses to bring up that Fiona and Jesse kissed last week and continue to annoy me with the lack of a love triangle between the three. Fiona meets with Michael where she tells him what happened, that she cares for Jesse (though not in a romantic way), and feels as if she owes him an apology more than anyone. All of that is great, and perfectly in character, but it isn’t affected at all by the fact that they kissed. She felt that way before that moment, so why bring it up again except to continue referencing an inane and frankly not all that existent subplot? Thankfully, Michael cares about it as little as I do, and agrees that Fiona should go find Jesse while he goes to rescue Scott’s daughter.

However, the plan blows up when Michael gets a gun to the side of the head. Dale had Scott’s ex-wife’s phone tapped and heard the whole thing when Scott told her about it. Michael’s only play is to barter with Dale, saying he can get him his brother back regardless of the guilty verdict. He’s just digging himself a deeper hole. Plan B is to seize Dale’s brother when he’s being moved from jail and complete what is essentially a prisoner exchange.

Fiona and Maddie go to meet Jesse, and when Jesse gives Fiona attitude, Maddie gives it right back. Win. However, Fiona explains why Jesse got burned and that they still need his help to get Barrett. Her one mistake is using the word “friends” in a sentence, which understandably does not sit well with him. She does, however, point out that everyone on this show has lied to everyone else at some point – Fiona met Michael under a cover ID, and Sam used to inform on Michael to the FBI (remember that?). The person who really gets through to Jesse, though, is Maddie. She tells him that all this BS is beneath him. The Jesse-Maddie friendship has always intrigued me, and it’s great to see it come to good use in this episode.

After that, Fiona kidnaps a guy she ran into outside a nightclub earlier in order for them to switch him out with Dale’s brother. The team hunts down the real prisoner transport van, with Michael and Dale trailing. This sequence teaches us today’s thing we can learn on Burn Notice: emergency vehicles can manipulate traffic lights with a light that strobes at the same frequency. Once the team rolls the van, Sam and Fiona swoop in to liberate Dale’s brother and take off with him. At least, that’s what Dale thinks. He turns Scott’s daughter over to them, and finds out too late that he’s been had. A lot of shooting ensues, but nobody hits anything (do they ever on TV?). The only problem is that now Dale is ticked off, so Michael warns Scott that he and his family probably need to flee the country. That’s not a great ending, but at least the guy got his kid back, and Michael picks up a free sub to boot.

Surprisingly, Jesse meets Michael, albeit after he has a debate with himself over whether or not to shoot him. Michael knows nothing he can say or do will make Jesse feel better, so he just appeals to Jesse’s sense of duty in asking for his help to eliminate Barrett. He knows that Jesse’s been working on this same case for years and no one will know Barrett better than Jesse will. Jesse at least agrees not to shoot him for the time being, which isn’t too bad considering the events of “Blind Spot” probably went down only a few days before, if that. Michael isn’t able to convince him to come along for the ride, however, which leaves the team one important man down.

Michael goes to meet with Barrett on his own (technically, as Fiona and Sam are covering his back), playing along as if he’s going to join the Axis of Evil. He actually hands over the Bible, and Barrett explains that the Bible is actually able to decipher a list of and information about the people who burned both Michael and Simon. However, he then gets a phone call, saying there’s a team of people coming to kick his ass. These people, of course, belong to Vaughn and very quickly start a shootout. However, when one of Barrett’s goons tries to grab Michael, someone makes a gutsy and life-saving move: shooting through Michael to disable the thug. That person is none other than Jesse Porter, and allow me to take a shallow moment to say that Coby Bell looks great holding a big firearm and wreaking havoc.

However, Barrett grabs Michael and shoves him into a car. Michael, however, is not a fan of this ride and wants off. He grabs the wheel, causing the SUV to roll with both of them inside. Still bleeding profusely, Michael struggles from the wreckage. Barrett is not so lucky, and on top of that, someone we don’t know grabs the suitcase now containing Simon’s Bible and walks off with it. In other words, the entire fracas is pretty much a loss: the Bible is gone, Barrett is dead, and Vaughn’s people have just screwed up everything. At least Jesse is back, though we still don’t know what’s going on in his head. Of course, then there’s the big fact that our hero is bleeding on the pavement. It really isn’t a good time to be Michael Westen. At least, not until the show comes back in November…

I find myself having mixed feelings toward this episode. Truthfully, it was never going to resolve everything set up in the first half of the season, or there would be no need for a second half. Yet especially on the heels of last week’s excellent episode, it didn’t deliver quite the same punch that I was hoping for. At least we did finally find out what the Bible decodes (I can only assume that the second half of the season will involve trying to recover it and find out the names on this alleged list), but not much else. Yes, there was a showdown of sorts between Michael, Barrett and Vaughn’s people…but not much of one. It was more a lot of shooting than anything else. Robert Patrick really wasn’t given all that much to do, which seems a bit of a waste.

Likewise, we didn’t get the explosive confrontation between Jesse and Michael that would have been fascinating to watch. As my colleague Jordan Cramer pointed out in his review, we didn’t even get that much of Coby Bell at all, which is a waste of character potential and acting talent. I’m glad that at least Jesse is willing to come back and help Michael, though I doubt everything is going to be suddenly copacetic between them; still, one brief scene between them arguing wasn’t quite what I was hoping for. Jesse was primed to explode last week, and apparently we missed all the exploding off-screen. It was a treat to see it being Maddie and Fiona, especially Maddie, confront him on his behavior, though, and do so using the entire history of the show to prove their point. The Burn Notice writers actually use their entire canon rather than write it and forget it.

Don’t get me wrong: I liked this episode, and it’s an interesting ending to the first half of the season, but it just didn’t do it for me completely. I would’ve liked to see it be more character and less action-driven. The characters certainly had enough to carry the story. The show set up a great final confrontation between Michael, Vaughn and Barrett, and another between Jesse and Michael (or at least Jesse and Fiona), but those storylines could have been so much more. I wonder if the episode would have been better had it left out a “case of the week” element (this one wasn’t one of my favorites, honestly) and just concentrated the entire forty-four minutes on its major climax. I’m still excited to see what happens in two months, but I also find myself thinking about what might have been. This episode did what it needed to do from a technical standpoint – break the season and leave it in an interesting place – but that’s all it did. It wasn’t the big blockbuster episode that we were teased, that fans were hoping for, or that it absolutely could have been with all the talent both in front of and behind the camera.

That said: who else is still incredibly excited for part two? In that respect, Burn Notice delivered.

  • Colleen Mengel

    I have to agree with you on the standalone story. It was extraneous and would have made for more excitement if they had saved it for another episode, fleshed it out a bit more. The potential was there. I think the lawyer comes back again in a later episode.
    The showdowns slated for this episode would have been more dramatic if they were the only focus last night. However, I do not think confrontations between Jesse and Michael are over yet. Nothing was resolved actually when Jesse told Michael "Between you and me, no promises." So I think there's room for a lot more working out of their issues. I liked what I saw though. I loved that they totally zeroed out an apology on Michael's part and went right to business. I also liked that Fiona had that conversation with Michael; I think it underlined that they are committed to one another in their own way. They have the most unique relationship I have ever seen and in that uniqueness, it continues to be tantalizing. Enough so that there is no need for a triangle; on that, you and I agree. I'm glad Fi and Maddie met with Jesse. I liked that scene also. Maddie was great and she will be the one to defuse things in the long run (I believe); I really don't think that is finished. That may be her great role this season.
    Big disappointment – no more Robert Barrett. He was a villain I was looking forward to seeing Michael take on. He was such a worthy opponent. I never liked Vaughn; hated that "buddy' attitude he copped with Michael. Maybe while the camera's focus was on Barrett's escape, Sam or Fiona managed to take him out. We have no idea what was going on back there. Hey – maybe November will open on that scene – like the next 11 weeks never happened! That would be cool!
    Oh, I did the total 16 hour marathon yesterday without a break and it was worth watching the entire season again in one sitting. Put a lot of things into perspective that I hadn't seen before.
    (Yes, I do work but school hasn't started yet and I have a TV in my sewing studio, where I spent the entire day creating! And watching!)

  • Brittany Frederick

    Oh, they can bring Danny Pino back (and yeah, they could if they wanted – his character didn't really get much closure) but I hope they leave Michael Rooker out of it. I've never liked his acting and I find him grating.

    I agree that things are definitely not back to okay with Jesse and Michael, but I'm still disappointed that there wasn't a bigger face-off between them this episode. That was what was advertised and it did not deliver. Obviously this ep picks up not long after the last ep so you'd think Jesse would still be running hot (and obviously he's got issues if he almost shot Michael before meeting him in the diner), but we didn't get to see him really in Michael's face too much. Or anyone's really. I'm sure they'll still have stuff to resolve in the back half (unless the writers take some big time jump forward), but it was a missed opportunity.

    And yes, it's a shame Robert Patrick is gone. I'm biased being a fan of his since I was a kid, but he was an amazing actor, and he could have done so much more. The scene with him and Michael in the SUV was pretty tense…and then he dies. As far as Vaughn, I don't have a clue where he is, nor do I care. He does get annoying after awhile, but I'm pretty sure since he's still alive, he'll end up rearing his head. It definitely didn't look like Jesse or Sam grabbing the suitcase with the Bible, so I have to assume it was either one of Barrett's men or one of Vaughn's (they all dress alike). Of course Vaughn will want the Bible to protect the identities of the people on Simon's list while Michael will probably want to know who they are…it's a whole other conflict.

    There's definitely story potential in the rest of the season, I just think this episode could have been great as opposed to just good.

  • JS

    I have to disagree, Danny Pino wasn't unreconizable with his stubble. I automatically reconized him, it was nice to see him back on TV, ever since CBS decided to cancel Cold Case.

    The episode was pretty neat.

  • Brittany Frederick

    Good for you, but I didn't figure it out until later on in the episode. The lighting really wasn't that great when he was on-screen initially, so that's probably part of it.

    And yeah, it was a neat episode.

  • JS

    my comment above wasn't personal against your opinion in anyways, if you took it as that.

    As for the show, I don't think I really got into it that well; the characters as well. Some shows grab me this didn't, but I figured since Danny Pino was in it; i'd check it out. Really didn't understand what was going on between the characters.

    • Brittany Frederick

      You probably had a better eye than I did. I also didn't watch Cold Case on a regular basis, so between that and the dark lighting I was probably not as well off as you in that department.

      And yeah, a lot of it had to do with an ongoing season-long storyline, so if you haven't seen the show before or have missed part of this season, it would go totally over your head.

    • Brittany Frederick

      With it being the summer finale, you had to have been following the plotline of the season to really get it. You didn't pick the best episode to jump in on. You'd probably be better off trying again when the show comes back in November!

  • Burn Notice Fanatic

    OMG I completely agree. Couldn't they have left the client out this time just like the last one? If it were left out then we would see a lot more character. The client case was about the worse in the season but what made the whole episode good was the suspense around Jesse, Vaughn, Michael and Barrett not the client or his problems.

    • Brittany Frederick

      I'm surprised that they tried to work a case into this episode, but, oh well. We'll see what they do with the next episode – how much time has passed, if they revisit some of the character conflicts they didn't touch on here.

      Thanks for reading!

Five Movies That Would End Up Making Great Shows
Dawson's Creek
10 Things You Didn’t Know About Dawson’s Creek
Baseball TV episodes
Our Favorite Baseball-Themed TV Episodes Of All-Time
lgbt tv show characters
Our Favorite LGBT TV Show Characters Of All-Time
The 20 Best Eyes in Hollywood
The 15 Most Ripped Actors of Past and Present
Eight of the Strangest Looking Actors in Hollywood
"The Master" Premiere - The 69th Venice Film Festival
12 Things You Never Knew about Philip Seymour Hoffman
Where Are They Now? The Cast of Menace II Society
Kids Larry Clark
Whatever Happened to the Cast of Kids?
The 15 Most Iconic Movie Masks of All Time
Dustin Hoffman - Straw Dogs (1971) 3
Five Incredible Revenge Movies Not Enough People Have Seen
Seven Live Performances By U2 That Absolutely Rocked
fall on stage
It Happens to Everyone: When Famous Musicians Fall on Stage
Lady Pank
Obscure 80s Music Videos That Are Extremely 80s
The Clash
International Clash Day: Seattle Honors London Band with Holiday
Seven Incredibly Dangerous Car Accidents in NASCAR History
Ever Wonder Why Peyton Manning Says Omaha All The Time?
Don’t Forget to Watch The NFL Honors 2016 Show
Josh Norman
When Is the Official Super Bowl Kick Off of 2016?

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.