Review: ABC’s Castle, starring Nathan Fillion

Bryan Jones March 1, 2009 12

113294_4520_preThere is quite possibly nothing more satisfying than reading a well put together mystery novel. Following your favorite sleuth, whether amateur or professional, along the winding road of a tough case can be very satisfying. Unfortunately, the television mystery series has garnered quite a bit less enthusiasm over the years due to clichés and plots that we’ve all seen time and time again. Nathan Fillion, star of the new ABC mystery series Castle, hopes to change our minds and give us something fresh and new.

Castle is a midseason replacement set to premiere on ABC on March 9. The official synopsis of the series says,

‘Wildly famous mystery novelist Richard Castle (Nathan Fillion) is bored with his own success. Then he learns that a real-world copycat killer has started staging murder scenes depicted in his novels. Castle is questioned by NYPD Detective Kate Beckett (Stana Katic), a bright and aggressive detective who keeps her investigations under tight rein. Though they instantly clash, sparks of another sort also begin to fly, leading both to danger and a hint of romance as Castle steps in to help find the killer. And once that case is solved, he and Beckett build on their new relationship as they look to solve more strange homicides in New York – as much fun as one can have with death and murder.’

TVOvermind recently had the opportunity to screen the new mystery series and I have to admit, as much as I love Nathan Fillion, I was a bit skeptical going into this one. There have been many mystery shows over the years, and as great as so many of them were, one word could pretty much sum up the episode plotlines. Cliché. So many television mysteries end up becoming nothing more than one predictable plotline after another. Although one episode of Castle alone can’t answer this question, the pilot episode does tell us one thing loud and clear, this isn’t the same old mystery series you’ve seen before.

Nathan Fillion plays the outwardly roguish, cocky, couldn’t-care-less Richard Castle with an ease unlike anyone else. His attitude and mannerisms almost make you want to hate him at first, but you can’t help but smile at the same time. In the opening scene, Castle is introduced to the stage while autographing a female fan’s breast. As he’s walking away from her he slyly says, ‘Call me when you’re ready to wash that.’Though we quickly learn, through several scenes with his teenage daughter, that Richard Castle does care, and you start to peel back the layers that separate the public persona that Castle exhibits to his fans, with the real Castle that he keeps safely hidden below the tough exterior.

To play the other side of Castle’s easy going, break the rules type, is Kate Beckett (Stana Katic), the street smart, straight-shooting detective. Beckett is somewhat of a closet Castle fan, though she attempts to never fall for his charm (she often fails miserably at this, however). Overall I enjoyed Katic’s portrayal of Kate Beckett, however I do have some concerns about the character being too one dimensional and flat as the series continues. In the pilot, it’s a bit difficult in a few scenes to see her as anything but a plot device used to allow us to focus more on Castle’s overall charm and wit. In fact, there is only one scene where her street-smart ways beat out Castle’s book-smart knowledge. If they want this show to stand the test of time, we really need to see a more rounded Kate Beckett character. If they can succeed in having her one-up Castle a little more often, and maybe even teach him a thing or two about real life crime solving, they’d have something even more amazing on the air.

What makes Castle really different from previous mystery shows, however, is the metafictional device they employ. You see, Richard Castle himself is a mystery writer, creating fake murder mysteries for his novels. He knows ever murder plot cliché out there, and makes these weak points and clichés known during the case they’re working on, which is also inadvertently pointing out the same weak points and clichés out to the audience about the show itself. It’s an interesting balancing act that makes the show amusingly self aware and entertaining to watch at the same time.

Overall I found the pilot episode of Castle to be fantastic and far above my expectations. If you’re a fan of the procedural mystery series with a little fun, you’ll definitely want to tune in for this show. I certainly didn’t think the show was flawless, and there is room for more improvement, but for a mid midseason replacement, it more than exceeds the expectations that I had for the show. I’ll be setting my DVR so that I don’t miss this one at all.

Castle is produced by ABC Studios and premieres on ABC on Monday, March 9 at 10pm (EST).

no images were found

  • Middayeclipse

    I saw my first commercial for this yesterday. I can’t tell you how long it’s been since an ad made me sit up and say, “Hey, that series looks *really* good!” I’ve always enjoyed Nathan Fillion’s projects and I’m hoping this lives up to the quality of his other work. I didn’t recognize Stana Katic from anywhere so she will be an unknown for me going in. From the brief glimpse, it looks smart and funny and not-shot-in-the-dark (yes, CSI and CSI-NY I’m talking to you.) I’m looking forward to having something to watch on Mondays now.

    • http://www.tvovermind.com/ AstroJones

      Yeah, Stana Katic was an unknown to me as well. And I’m totally with you on the CSI and CSI-NY comments. I’ll be checking out some other future episodes of Castle soon, so I’ll let you know if the show is continuing to look good and get better!

  • Middayeclipse

    I saw my first commercial for this yesterday. I can't tell you how long it's been since an ad made me sit up and say, "Hey, that series looks *really* good!" I've always enjoyed Nathan Fillion's projects and I'm hoping this lives up to the quality of his other work. I didn't recognize Stana Katic from anywhere so she will be an unknown for me going in. From the brief glimpse, it looks smart and funny and not-shot-in-the-dark (yes, CSI and CSI-NY I'm talking to you.) I'm looking forward to having something to watch on Mondays now.

    • http://www.tvovermind.com/ AstroJones

      Yeah, Stana Katic was an unknown to me as well. And I'm totally with you on the CSI and CSI-NY comments. I'll be checking out some other future episodes of Castle soon, so I'll let you know if the show is continuing to look good and get better!

  • RavenRants

    I used to really enjoy the tongue-in-cheek investigative caper show, I think it’s why I enjoy Bones so much, so I’m pretty exited to see this come out.

    Pity about the one-note Detective, I hope she gets flushed-out as the series progresses.

    But really, I’ll watch just about anything that has Nathan Fillion hamming it up on-screen.

    • http://www.tvovermind.com/ AstroJones

      I agree on the tongue-in-cheek investigation caper shows. I loved them so much when I was younger, and over the years. But I just got to where I couldn’t stand to watch many of them in more recent years. I’ve read a few reviews that said they didn’t think the chemistry between Fillion and Stana Katic was as good as Bones, but that it was comparable. And I have faith that the detective will get better. The Pilot episode was very much about introducing us to Fillion’s character.

  • RavenRants

    I used to really enjoy the tongue-in-cheek investigative caper show, I think it's why I enjoy Bones so much, so I'm pretty exited to see this come out.

    Pity about the one-note Detective, I hope she gets flushed-out as the series progresses.

    But really, I'll watch just about anything that has Nathan Fillion hamming it up on-screen.

    • http://www.tvovermind.com/ AstroJones

      I agree on the tongue-in-cheek investigation caper shows. I loved them so much when I was younger, and over the years. But I just got to where I couldn't stand to watch many of them in more recent years. I've read a few reviews that said they didn't think the chemistry between Fillion and Stana Katic was as good as Bones, but that it was comparable. And I have faith that the detective will get better. The Pilot episode was very much about introducing us to Fillion's character.

  • Pingback: BC Review » Blog Archive » Castle: ABC

  • Pingback: “Castle” ABC TV Series starring Nathan Fillion & Stana Katic » Blog Archive » Far Above Expectations

  • http://dustinweishaar.myopenid.com/ Chloe Beadle

    I really love Nathan as an actor. Thanks for the post. A perfect topic for my custom essays

  • http://www.breastpumpdeals.com/medela-freestyle-breast-pump.html Freestyle Medela

    Thank you.