Comic Book Men 1.01 “Pilot” Series Premiere Review

Comic Book Men - Series PremiereComic Book Men, a reality series from acclaimed director Kevin Smith debuts its series premiere on AMC tonight following The Walking Dead, focusing on the day-to-day running of his New Jersey comic book shop Jay and Silent Bob’s Secret Stash. An unusual effort for AMC, Comic Book Men might require a bit of tweaking if it wishes to succeed going forward.

As usual, we need to get one thing straight first. I don’t watch reality TV. That isn’t a critique against reality TV mind you, and even I’ve been known to take in the occasional Jersey Shore, or something random that particularly peaks my interest, but on the whole I find myself incapable of acclimating to the conditions reality TV expects. Like watching sports, there’s never any moment of reality TV in which I understand what’s being asked of me. Are any parts of it real, or are we ourselves expected where to decide where the suspension of disbelief lies?

I may not be an avid comic book reader either, but I consider myself within the pantheon of nerdery, to the point where I might be the only person at bar trivia who recognizes the name ‘Ultron,’but would never in a million years make the kind of purchases or sales outlined within Jay and Silent Bob’s Secret Stash, the focus and setting of Comic Book Men. However, I do consider myself a fan of the works of Kevin Smith, and trust in his direction enough to at least give Comic Book Men an honest approach, reality TV though it may be.

It’s also interesting to consider AMC’s decision to pick up Comic Book Men in the first place, obviously in need of something to fill the post-Walking Dead slot after the Hell on Wheels finale, and clearly trying to attract more of the Walking Dead‘s comic fanbase to AMC programming. AMC is also a network still unsure of what to do with its new-found accolades, as such experimenting with new formats like reality TV, so the performance of Comic Book Men may determine some of their programming strategies in the future.

Now as I said, I’m not terribly familiar with most reality TV, therefore I couldn’t tell you exactly what shows Comic Book Men picks and chooses from, as it drifts through a number of formats for the first episode. The series focuses on four men hanging around Kevin Smith’s New Jersey comic shop Jay and Silent Bob’s Secret Stash, manager Walter, oft-teased employee Ming, Mike, and the exceptionally bearded and acerbic non-employee Brian. They anchor the goings-on somewhat with a roundtable podcast hosted by Kevin Smith, in a sort of Tarantino-esque recap of the individual anecdotes of life working in this shop.

And that’s more or less where things become a little aimless with Comic Book Men, as it drifts between a number of different angles with which to present this world, darting between Clerks-esque dissection of pop culture and comics, and Pawn Stars-style appraisals of their quirky customers’memorabilia. There are also a number of events that take place outside the store, as Ming and Brian compete to sell off the Stash’s excess merchandise at a local flea market, but once again we’ve yet to see a clear picture of why we’re investing in these men. I’m not one to judge or throw labels at these guys, but forgive me if I can’t gather a reason to watch middle-aged men enthusiastically ruminate on mediums and eras long since obsolete.

There’s such a fascinating world taking place within the comic book zeitgeist currently, from DC’s big overhauls to all the Marvel films stealing spotlight, that it might be nice to draw a bit of attention to more current scenes rather than pore over artwork and tropes of a bygone era. At the very least, a more youthful presence around the shop would do wonders for attracting the type of audience they’re hoping for.

On the whole, Comic Book Men is worth a look, and certainly worth a few laughs in the unique characters and witty banter, but the pilot itself skews too broad for too small of an audience to attract any real attention. If anything, I’d be more interested to know what true comic fans, young and old, thought of the premiere.

And Another Thing…

  • To its credit, I did appreciate the show’s efforts to display characters, and facts the Comic Book Men reference for the purpose of helping along audiences who might not be familiar.
  • Characters like the various caricatured collectors looking to hawk their wars are exactly why I don’t watch reality TV, given that they feel positioned to be memorable, rather inorganically.

What did YOU think?

  • justin

    i thought the show sucked. the show was like a trip to the dentist, familiar but painful nonetheless.

  • NJShoreChick

    Ruminating over a bygone era is what collecting this stuff is all about. Really, how many kids under 25 know who the heck Steve Austin is? If it weren't for us "over 40's" ruminating, Facebook would have faded away before the last hangover at Harvard and Ebay would be just another website. Seeking to grasp at the vestiges of our youth, we cast a wide net for that last "Ker-plunk!" with all of it's marbles, or an H.R. Pufnstuf bobblehead for our desk just so we can remember sitting on the porch on a hot day in 1972. These guys have captured that in little sound bites, and it revolves around comics and collectibles. I'm interested in seeing where this goes, as we occasionally pop into the store (but will be avoiding it during taping) and look forward to seeing the other "geeks" among us. We all covet something – what's your thing?

    • Kevin Fitzpatrick

      I'll be interested in seeing where the series goes as well, but my point was that its first episode wasn't the most accessible from a general standpoint. It's clear that AMC is looking to appeal to its more nerd-culture viewers by positioning Comic Book Men behind The Walking Dead, but at least in this first episode Comic Book Men skews toward a much older demographic, without a clear sense of identity in what kind of story it presents. In some places, nerd culture can be just as alienating as anything else, and it's a risky maneuver to position a show around items and concepts half its viewers might not be familiar with.

  • NotaFan

    This show was a total let down. From the grammer school humor and unwitty banter to quote “Santas Evil Twin” it was dreadful. And what was the deal with the zit on the dudes face? Was that left on purpose for the geek effect? I’m surprised it lasted past the first commercial.

  • Robert Bruce

    what should i say ..I live , Breathe, eat and pretty much sh!t this stuff, completely immersed this show is for those like me, and I know they exist ( I have met you) for too long have we hidden our in-geek in the dark , time to shine some light on our obsession..long live the Nerd!! Love live the Comic Book men…

  • John Meyers

    Loved it! But I am also a huge fan of Tell em' Steve Dave so I loved it before I ever saw it as I knew it would be great.

  • Damascus

    I’d love to see at least one review from some author who has actually bothered to go and listen to some of the Tell ’em Steve Dave podcasts or anything on the Smodcast network. It’d be nice to hear what an actual fan of Kevin, Walt, Bryan, et. al., had to say about it. I’ve read multiple reviews and the reviewer seems to be someone who saw Clerks once and that’s it. No disrespect intended for this reviewer, I’d just like to see a true fan’s point of view. An honest POV too, not just gargling Steve-Dave balls either. I liked it, keep it up and us TESDees will always be there watching.

The Curse of Good Sci-Fi TV
Billions Season 1 Episode 4 Review: “Short Squeeze”
Why There Should Be More Puppets in Prime Time Television
Five TV Neighbors That Would be a Total Nightmare in Real Life
Eight of the Strangest Looking Actors in Hollywood
"The Master" Premiere - The 69th Venice Film Festival
12 Things You Never Knew about Philip Seymour Hoffman
'Andrew Lincoln and Robert Kirkman Attend 'The Walking Dead' Premiere in Madrid
12 Things You Didn’t Know About Andrew Lincoln
Seven Celebrities With Strange Physical Flaws
Coach Finstock
Coach Bobby Finstock from Teen Wolf Gives the Best Advice Ever
Time to Kill
10 Incredibly Powerful Movies That Center Around Racism
A List of Movies with Numbers in the Title, From 1 to 25
Potter Fan
Harry Potter in Japan: Harry’s Biggest and Craziest Fan in History
Seven Live Performances By U2 That Absolutely Rocked
fall on stage
It Happens to Everyone: When Famous Musicians Fall on Stage
Lady Pank
Obscure 80s Music Videos That Are Extremely 80s
The Clash
International Clash Day: Seattle Honors London Band with Holiday
Seven Incredibly Dangerous Car Accidents in NASCAR History
Ever Wonder Why Peyton Manning Says Omaha All The Time?
Don’t Forget to Watch The NFL Honors 2016 Show
Josh Norman
When Is the Official Super Bowl Kick Off of 2016?

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.