Tonight’s season 2 premiere of Don’t Trust the B— in Apt. #23 is a big James Van Der Beek episode and he deserves a lot of laughs for his comedic timing. As the episode begins, James receives his yearly “please join the Dawson’s Creek reunion” letter from Josh Jackson, Katie Holmes and Michelle Williams. But every year he resists their plea to reunite, happy to be the one hold-out because he thinks it gives him power.
Enter June, who loved the show when she was a teenager. She begs James to go through with it, despite Chloe’s insistence that he should be looking forward and not back. When James does decide to do the reunion, he’s kind of shocked to discover that his former co-stars are all angry with him. So he calls Busy Phillips, who appeared on the show for a few seasons. Unfortunately, she has to deliver the bad news about why the rest of the cast hates him. Mark-Paul Gosselaar and Frankie Muniz both guest star.
Don’t miss the season premiere of Don’t Trust the B— in Apt. #23 tonight at 9:30 p.m. ET/PT on ABC.