Darkest episode of LOST ever? Quite possibly. "Sundown," was a wonderful title because it had many meanings, including the obvious one from the context of the episode. However, I think it also had that wonderful double meaning of the sundown in Sayid's "scale" between good and evil, and a possible sundown for the tone of the series as a whole.
The episode was one of those kickass actioners you usually only see once a season (i.e. "Homecoming," for season 1, "The Shape of Things to Come," for season 4) and did it deliver. I don't think that even "The Shape of Things to Come" had such a dramatic impact as "Sundown" did. Sure, nobody really major died (Sayid's soul notwithstanding), but the character development in this episode remained really, really strong (as it was in last week's "Lighthouse" and the week before's "The Substitute"). Sayid was developed in his descent down into darkness, and I hope there's some redemption for him in either this universe or the other.
As far as deaths in the episode went, Dogen's came rather suddenly, though I wouldn't be surprised if we saw him again, if only in flashback. I had kind of figured Lennon was going to go as well, but he was so brutally murdered by Sayid that it was shocking for me. I hate that, too; he was my favorite Other, if only for his Beatles-referential name.
And that was only in one timeline. The reset timeline featured the return of Keamy and Omar, who apparently enjoyed going to "Eggtown" while they extorted debts from Sayid's brother and kidnapped Jin. That storyline will presumably pop back up soon, even if Keamy and Omar were killed once again (It's likely we'll see them again in Jin's flash-sideways episode).
The rest of Sayid's flash-sideways was a little sleepy, except for the really interesting dynamic between Sayid and Nadia, who married Sayid's brother in this timeline. What a twist. He's one of the first cases we've had where the reset timeline isn't necessarily that great compared to the original timeline.
The Island storyline was very interesting, though. Sayid finally got around to demanding answers, and was manipulated by Dogen into attempting to kill the Man in Black with a knife (in hopes that the Man in Black would kill Sayid). Silly Sayid soon found out the truth, and returned the favor to Dogen by drowning him (and then he cut Lennon's throat). Dogen's death appears to have given the MIB free reign in the Temple (Why? Good question.)
Meanwhile, the Man in Black sent Claire in, and she imprisoned by the Others, where she found out that Kate had actually taken care of Aaron while she left. But we never really found out why the Man in Black sent her in in the first place. The message he wanted to convey was actually delivered by Sayid. Whassa deal, MIB?
Then there was the wonderful matter of the Man in Black's ultimatum: join me or die. In keeping with his "one chance" policy, he decided to wipe out those who remained in the Temple after sundown. And wipe out he did. Kate would have died if she hadn't jumped in the prison pit with Claire (who surprisingly didn't go all "my baybee!" and try to kill Kate, like she had told Jin she would last week), and Miles would have been toast if Ilana and crew hadn't shown up just in time to use Jacob's secret passage to escape from the carnage.In the meantime, Miles gave Sun yet some more hope that Jin was alive. After a season and change of the two being apart, if that reunion is anything less than tearjerking, it'll be a surprise.
Ben, now apparently trying to be a hero (and doing a pretty good job at it, too) tried to bring Sayid along, but after discovering that Sayid was no longer himself (or was more of himself than ever; that's up for debate) put on his scared face and fled into the shadows. Ben's still a coward, but he's a cool coward at that.
And then, to cap off the episode, there was, without a doubt, the creepiest scene ever. Forget Claire's dream from season one, and forget the bear skull baby in her crib (all the really creepy stuff seems to revolve around Claire, doesn't it?). No, the creepiest scene of LOST ever was Sayid and Claire's tiptoe through the carnage, eerily overlapped with Claire singing "Catch a Falling Star." It was spine-tingling, especially when overlapped with the fact that these two Losties who we used to know and love, are now at least partially responsible for the awful carnage they're walking through.
Wow.
The two (along with Kate) reunite with the Man in Black, who is waiting on the outside of the Temple, and they set off into the jungle, for an uncertain future.
It was the best episode of the season, and it definitely proved that season six, which started unsteadily, is in full roar from here on out. A+
Check out promo photos for the March 9 new episode of LOST.
MiB sent Claire in before Sayid came out; the problem with that plan is the Others thought she was a loon and didn't take her as seriously as they did when Sayid came back.And I disagree that Sayid & Nadia aren't better off in the AR. Nadia is roadkill in the on-island timeline.
Meh, I didn't think it was very good at all, bit of an anti climax really, the last act all felt a bit cheap
Locke sent Claire in first to tell Dogen that he wanted to speak with him. Locke was obviously not able to step foot in the temple at this time so he needed to send Claire as his messanger. This was pretty obvious when Claire explained this to Dogen, and also when Locke explained it to Claire beforehand.And I also think Sayid is much better off in the sideways story than the island story. He may not be married to Nadia, but at least she's still alive. Not to mention the fact that he knows where she is and sees her on a semi-regular basis. I'd take that over searching for a woman my entire life, only to have her die right after marrying her.And no way was this episode mor action-packed than TSOTTC. That episode was non-stop from beginning to end. This week's episode had a lot of downtime. Wasn't bad though. Much better than that awful Kate episode from a few weeks back.
The flash-sideways still doesn’t really work without out know what the connection is, but with the 2007 Sayid paralleling island Sayid in very different circumstances, it worked out quite well. I’m not sure if we’ll be able to get that each week since Sayid works perfectly in the duality.Was anyone expecting Sayid to kill both Dogen and Lennon? That totally caught me by surprise, because I thought Dogen would play a big role. I’ll be disappointed if this is the last we see of Hiroyuki Sanada. Review of the episode on my blog:http://th3tvobsessed.blogspot.com/2010/03/revie…..
Not really, it didn't. SOTTC was a lot of standoffs, and the only real action was the Barracks exploding and Smokey coming in to kill the mercs. This episode had a long fistfight, and an even longer monster kill sequence.
I was thinking more main-character Sayid than Nadia.
Yeah, but wouldn't he rather have her alive and with his brother than dead?
[...] TV Overmind [...]
"He's one of the first cases we've had where the reset timeline isn't necessarily that great compared to the original timeline."WHAT??? Are you kidding? Nadia was KILLED in the original timeline. Here, she is alive and well, and obviously still loves Sayid!! That she is married to his brother is a minor complication, especially considering that the brother looks prone to geting himself killed.
LOST isn't about the action anyway, it's about the tension leading up to the action…
Well in both cases, Sayid doesn't get to be with Nadia. However, the storylines for Locke and Jack in the alternoverses are full of mainly good things.
I think Dogen and Lennon will be back….Remember, they were killed in a pool that usually gives back life. Hmmmm. Wonder what could happen there? Anybody, anybody?
Then don't watch it. Actually, your comment is "Meh" inducing too. Too many people are using that word that it has lost its meaning.