There’s a Really Freaky Theory about Dumbledore’s Sister Out There

There’s a great deal of conjecture and theory still surrounding Albus Dumbledore, the headmaster of Hogwarts in the Harry Potter series. Even after the end of the films, well after Albus’ demise, it is reasoned that his possession of the elder wand, the most powerful wand in existence, was gained by some other means than defeating his good friend Gellert Grindelwald. In fact one fan has deduced that Albus’ sister Ariana had a lot more to do with this. If you remember her from the books she was described as being confined to their home after a run-in with three muggle boys that forced the senior Dumbledore, father to Ariana, Albus, and Aberforth, to be absent for much of their lives.

Then an accidental flare up of magic, an obscurus, took their mother, leaving the three as orphans and needing to stick together. Aberforth went back to school while Albus stayed with Ariana to take care of her. Yet when he befriended Grindelwald things started getting a little chaotic.

The reason Grindelwald is so interested in controlling an obscurus is because he was overpowered by Ariana.

Ariana is an obscurus, and during the fight that ultimately lead to her death, she was able to overpower Grindelwald and take his wand from him, perhaps in her confused attempt to save Aberforth from the cruciatus curse. In the fight, it was Albus that killed her, which is why he was later able to defeat Grindelwald.

This timeline means that Grindelwald had the elder wand before going to Godric’s Hollow and meeting Albus. There would have been time because Aberforth says that he was “about to go back to school” after they had “known each other a few weeks.” This means that Grindelwald was doing something else at the beginning of the summer after leaving Durmstrang, researching and stealing the wand. He was already aware of the Hallows before meeting Albus so this is possible.

During the fight the elder wand’s allegiance shifted to Ariana, and then to Albus. This is why Albus took so long to fight Grindelwald, he knew that it would confirm that it was he who had killed Ariana. It did, and he lived with that for the rest of his life.

Grindelwald took none of the blame for Ariana even though it was his blind ambition that led him towards the desire for an Obscurial to control. If you watched Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them then you saw as Grindelwald went after another Obscurial as well, with just as little success and the end result being his imprisonment. That of course would only spark off another round of trouble that we might be seeing in the sequel whenever it comes out.

The sad part of this is that Albus was very much responsible for his sister’s death, directly so in fact. Whether it was to gain the power of the elder wand or to put Ariana out of her misery it seems Albus Dumbledore was not quite the kind and reserved man that he came to be later on. But obviously he was a very tortured human being no matter how he turned out.


Leave a Reply

Pegg and Frost Working on New Horror-comedy TV Series
Stephen King Wants To See A Law & Order Vampire Show
No Preview
Netflix’s Castlevania Gets an Order for 8 More Episodes
Devin Ratray AKA Buzz From Home Alone Now Starring in Mosaic
The Movie ‘Flight of the Navigator’ is Getting a Remake
The Five Worst Movies of 2017 According to The Razzies
2018’s Unlikeliest Best Picture Nominees (Are the Ones You Should Be Watching)
The Empire Strikes Back vs. The Last Jedi (Comic)
Someone Put Wii Music Over A Final Destination Death Scene and It’s Pretty Tense
The Top Uses of Willie Nelson’s “On The Road Again” in Movies or TV
The Top Uses of Tears for Fears Song ‘Everybody Wants to Rule the World’ in Movies or TV
The Top Uses of Cyndi Lauper’s “True Colors” in Movies or TV
The Best True Professional Hockey Story of All-Time: Eddie Shore
DePaul Hoops Walk On is Becoming a Celebrity for his Bench Antics
Check out Shaq’s Tree of all The Rims He Tore Down in his Career
LaVar Ball’s New 16,000 Square Foot House Tour Will Annoy You Even More
Guy Builds 15-Minute Long ‘Aliens’ Themed Roller Coaster In Sim Game
Mom Confronts Son about Porn While He’s Live Streaming Video Games
Looks like the Game Boy Classic Edition is Making a Return
The Three Best VR Games of 2017 for Oculus Rift
No Preview
Five Things You Didn’t Know About Glenn Greenwald
Five Things You Didn’t Know About Haley Bennett
The Uncharted Movie Is Being Rewritten (Again!)
Five Things You Didn’t Know about Nazanin Boniadi