This is hands down the laugh I needed before bed tonight...
According to the Syfy Wire, there is a a war going on between Stargate Universe's producer, Brad Wright, and the Chicago Tribune's Maureen Ryan over a review for ABC's 'V'.
Where does all this fit in with each other?
Well Ms. Ryan's review of 'V' included a swipe at Stargate Universe, which prompted Mr. Wright to comment on the article in the comments section. Mr. Wright's comment ruffled the feathers of Ms. Ryan enough for her to rebuttal with yet another article, this time focusing entirely on Mr. Wright's comments.
A lot of the comments on the second article include rants and raves for Maureen standing by her beliefs and calls for an apology from Brad Wright. Here is a link to the second article.
Post your thoughts because I am dying to hear them!
Source: SyFy Wire
I’m enjoying SGU very much, I find it superior to it’s predecessors (or at least Atlantis) and I have to respectfully disagree with Maureen.
I'm enjoying SGU very much, I find it superior to it's predecessors (or at least Atlantis) and I have to respectfully disagree with Maureen.
As a huge supporter of SGU it pains me to take a step back and actually support Mo Ryan on this. There are perfectly sound reasons to not like SGU, as there are for ANY show whether it is your favorite or not, and no-one deserves to be belittled directly for their opinion. Only indirectly. ;).
But seriously, it’s a battle of opinions and nobody is going to be injured – so let them at it!
As a huge supporter of SGU it pains me to take a step back and actually support Mo Ryan on this. There are perfectly sound reasons to not like SGU, as there are for ANY show whether it is your favorite or not, and no-one deserves to be belittled directly for their opinion. Only indirectly. ;).
But seriously, it's a battle of opinions and nobody is going to be injured – so let them at it!
I’m sorry that Brad Wright stuck his foot into it. The show producers already have alienated the fan base in the way that they canceled SGA at the same time that they announced SGU. What they don’t need is for the perception to grow that they are bitter and petty and dismissive of constructive or honest criticism. Brad Wright won’t win this one on so many levels because of the tone of his attack.
I have to agree with Jon on this one. In fact, I really have been enjoying SGU so far. With that said, as I read Mo’s comments there were several times that I couldn’t help but think, “yep, she does have a point there.” or “oh yeah, they could do that much better.” I just wish they would work on some of the issues and try to make it better. Try to understand your critics issues, and then decide whether their constructive ideas you can use to make positive change, or if they’re pointless and can be ignored.
I'm sorry that Brad Wright stuck his foot into it. The show producers already have alienated the fan base in the way that they canceled SGA at the same time that they announced SGU. What they don't need is for the perception to grow that they are bitter and petty and dismissive of constructive or honest criticism. Brad Wright won't win this one on so many levels because of the tone of his attack.
I have to agree with Jon on this one. In fact, I really have been enjoying SGU so far. With that said, as I read Mo's comments there were several times that I couldn't help but think, "yep, she does have a point there." or "oh yeah, they could do that much better." I just wish they would work on some of the issues and try to make it better. Try to understand your critics issues, and then decide whether their constructive ideas you can use to make positive change, or if they're pointless and can be ignored.
I absolutely adore the makers of Stargate. They are really great guys. I loved every bit of their sg universe until it turned to a painful to watch, dark, dramatical soap opera with guys having sex in random constellations.
Brad Wright gave maureen the advice to wait for a few episodes to come. Well, i would say that was a good joke. It’s getting worse, in absolutely every imagineable aspect.
Let’s hope mr. wright and mr. cooper will listen to the fanbase wich is pretty much on fire over this.
regards
I absolutely adore the makers of Stargate. They are really great guys. I loved every bit of their sg universe until it turned to a painful to watch, dark, dramatical soap opera with guys having sex in random constellations.
Brad Wright gave maureen the advice to wait for a few episodes to come. Well, i would say that was a good joke. It's getting worse, in absolutely every imagineable aspect.
Let's hope mr. wright and mr. cooper will listen to the fanbase wich is pretty much on fire over this.
regards