Supernatural 7.17 Review: You Broke It, You Bought It…Or, Is This What Redemption Looks Like?

Supernatural - The Born-Again Identity (Ed Araquel/The CW)A curious thing has happened to Supernatural. However you may feel about Sera Gamble as a showrunner and however you may feel about the season-long arcs (which, admittedly, I have had a few problems with lately), the truth is that Ms. Gamble has emerged as one of the strongest writers on the show. Together with Ben Edlund, Gamble has, this season, delivered (in my humble opinion) three consistently solid episodes. Episodes that not only do justice to the Winchesters, but also to the other two characters that make up the core of Supernatural: Castiel and Bobby.

This week’s episode, “The Born-Again Identity”, not only re-introduced Castiel and Misha Collins to the show, but it also reminded me why I love Supernatural. For all of the frustration that some fans may have on both sides of the Castiel argument, the truth is that he has become an important character on this show. When used properly – as he was in this episode – he doesn’t detract from the core of the Winchesters, he just fits.

So a Crazy Guy Walks Into an Alley…

Sam has been suffering since “Repo Men”. Lucifer is relentless in his torment of the younger Winchester brother and his constant attempts to interact with Sam have resulted in four sleepless days and nights. When Dean passed out, Sam went hunting for some drugs to help himself. But Lucifer is always there…always waiting to bait or goad or bother Sam. When Sam once again tried to outrun his own mind, he gets hit by a car.

Dean managed to track him down, but he hasn’t been properly briefed on Sam’s condition. While his brother is suffering from a broken rib and some lacerations, the doctors are far more concerned about Sam’s mental state. His lack of sleep and the hallucinations have landed him in the mental ward. Dean went to visit Sam who is, clearly, running out of options. He’ll die if Lucifer doesn’t allow him to sleep and he simply doesn’t know what they can do to fix this situation. Referencing the season 1 episode “Faith” (which bore many similarities to this episode), Sam acknowledged that finding someone who can legitimately heal him will be difficult, if not down-right impossible.

Never Give Up, Never Surrender

Dean wasn’t prepared to hear that, so he set out for Rufus’ cabin in order to find a friend of Bobby’s who could help him. Leaving messages for every hunter he could reach didn’t yield results. Not until a card mysteriously fell out of Bobby’s journal…one that very well could have been pulled out by Ghost Bobby. Fortunately, this led him to a hunter that referred him to a healer who appeared to be legitimate: a man named Emmanuel.

Dean headed off immediately. Arriving at Emmanuel’s house, he encountered the first of many demons who have decided to ignore Crowley’s “hands off the Winchesters” order because they sure haven’t done anything for the King of Hell lately. Dean managed to kill the demon that had taken Emmanuel’s wife hostage and then up stepped the man he’s been looking for: Castiel (er…Emmanuel).

You see, as we later learn, Cas emerged from that lake months ago – naked, natch – and stumbled upon Daphne, a lovely woman who took him in without question and helps nurture his gift of healing. Dean was gobsmacked, because he doesn’t entirely seem to believe Castiel’s amnesia and he certainly doesn’t know how to act around his former friend and ally turned enemy (?).

Supernatural - The Born-Again Identity (Ed Araquel/The CW)Blast from the Past

Dean was keeping quiet about Castiel’s true identity, but he did clue him in on what happened to Sam. He admited that someone did this to his brother – broke him – and that he can’t just shake off this kind of betrayal. Dean has been scarred many times over by the people he loves: his father, Sam, and Cas. His hesitation to trust – to forgive – is nothing but understandable. As Castiel so eloquently put it, Dean is not a machine, he’s just human. Supernatural struck the right balance with Dean in this episode. He wasn’t too proud not to ask for Castiel’s help and he certainly wasn’t going to up and kill him, but that doesn’t mean he could welcome him back with open arms.

While stopping for some food, Dean once again came upon some demons, who continued to be out in full force. Ruby’s knife continued to prove itself handy, but when he got into a bind it was Meg (guest star Rachel Miner) who saved the day. She admitted that she had been following for a while and was also shocked about Castiel since, to the best of her knowledge, he was supposed to be dead. Still on Crowley’s “bad” list, Meg wanted to team up with Dean, hoping that maybe Castiel might come in handy. He agreed to let her tag along, but he ordered her to keep quiet about Cas’ past.

Castiel – who could see the true face of demons – was shocked about Meg’s addition to the car ride, but quickly sucked it up.

Concluded on next page…

36 Comments

  1. Kate March 24, 2012
  2. @Romilys_J March 24, 2012
  3. Clarissa March 24, 2012
    • Furrina March 25, 2012
      • Clarissa March 25, 2012
  4. @IAmSteamgirl March 24, 2012
  5. Thomas March 24, 2012
  6. Suse March 24, 2012
  7. Evie March 24, 2012
  8. JoPN March 24, 2012
  9. Laurie March 24, 2012
    • Restless March 24, 2012
  10. @padakitty March 24, 2012
    • Janicec678 March 24, 2012
    • Ashley March 24, 2012
    • @SweetMind March 24, 2012
    • Guest March 25, 2012
  11. Lissa March 24, 2012
  12. courtney March 24, 2012
  13. Luciano March 24, 2012
  14. Janicec678 March 24, 2012
  15. Amy March 24, 2012
    • Restless March 24, 2012
  16. Restless March 24, 2012
  17. Meow_Aaals March 24, 2012
  18. imjustafan March 24, 2012
  19. @ravenclawwit March 24, 2012
  20. worrynet March 24, 2012
    • Clarissa March 24, 2012
  21. Guest March 25, 2012
  22. Supernatural Fan March 25, 2012
    • Restless March 26, 2012
  23. imjustafan March 25, 2012
  24. Terry March 26, 2012
  25. Conniekandoit March 26, 2012
  26. roylt84 March 27, 2012

Leave a Reply

When Famous Pop Culture Characters Get The Simpsons Treatment
What the Cast of Smallville Looks like Today
I Totally Forgot to Watch Britney Ever After Tonight!
A Golden Girls-Themed Cafe is Now Officially Open
B.D. Wong’s Top Five Movie Roles of All-Time
Ten Movie and TV Theme Parks I’d Like to See Happen in Real Life
Thea Trinidad AKA Rosita is Cast in WWE Film about Diva Paige
Five Incredibly Real Parenting Moments in Movies
Performing Rush’s “Tom Sawyer” Simultaneously Playing Drums, Guitar, and Singing
Saved By The Bell Mashup with Fifth Harmony’s “Work from Home”
Kid Rock Might be a Senate Candidate in Michigan’s 2018 Race
Aaron Carter Thinks Justin Bieber Should be Worried about Him
No Chance We See an Aaron Gordon and Zach Levine 2016 Dunk Contest
Dear Steve Kerr: Please Run Westbrook at Point with the Warriors
Zion Williamson Needs to Be in the NBA Dunk Contest Tonight
Fedor Emelianenko’s Bellator Debut Has Been Canceled
Bowser Woodwork is What Dedication is All About
Street Fighter II’s M. Bison Loses to Toyota in New C-HR Ad
Overwatch Gets GoldenEye Treatment in New Fan Video
New DLC For Mortal Kombat X is None Other than Grammy CeeLo
1970 Natalie Wood Photo is What Style was All About
This Guy is Eating a Picture of Jason Segel Every Day Until Segel Reciprocates
Alanis Morissette Loses Over $2 Million in Jewelry in Home Burglary
April Gloria Looks More Like Taylor Swift than Taylor Swift

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.