Supernatural Toronto Convention: Stories from a First-Timer (Plus, Photos!)

As much as I love being part of the Supernatural fandom, I have to admit that I had never been to a convention before this weekend. Fortunately, Creation Entertainment finally organized a Supernatural convention in my hometown of Toronto, so it was only a short trip to attend my very first “con”.

I’ve attended the Supernatural panels at Comic-Con and have interviewed the actors before – in San Diego and during a visit last week to Vancouver (read more here), so I didn’t think this experience would be very different. And it wasn’t that different from hearing the screaming fans at Comic-Con. It was just a lot more intense. It’s one thing to be at a convention with 100,000 people who all enjoy different shows, but there’s something far more intensified about being in a room with only a few hundred people who are incredibly passionate about one show. And people dress up far more for Supernatural cons than I ever saw dressed up for the panel at Comic-Con.

The audience at the con is also 99% women.

What was terrific about the con was that I had the opportunity to see several Supernatural actors I’ve never seen in person before. The guest list for the Toronto con consisted of:

  • Jensen Ackles (Dean Winchester)
  • Jared Padalecki (Sam Winchester)
  • Misha Collins (Castiel)
  • Matt Cohen (Young John Winchester)
  • Amy Gumenick (Young Mary Campbell)
  • Gabriel Tigerman (Andrew Gallagher)
  • Richard Speight, Jr. (Trickster/Gabriel)
  • Corin Nemec (Christian Campbell)
  • Traci Dinwiddie (Pamela Barnes)
  • Damon Runyan (Jenny’s Boyfriend in Dead Man’s Blood and Dream a Little Dream of Me)
  • Julian Richings (Death)
  • Elias Toufexis (Weber/Ansen Weems in Simon Said)
  • Clif Kosterman (Tiny in Folsom Prison Blues and Jared & Jensen’s bodyguard)

Matt Cohen was a perfect person to open the convention and the person I was most excited about seeing, as I have never seen him live before. Not only is he ridiculously charming and gorgeous, he’s an absolute sweetheart. Cohen preferred to walk around the room instead of remaining on stage, bringing the microphone right up to fans to ask a question and giving them a hug. Richard Speight loved to walk the crowd as well. Couple those panels with Traci Dinwiddie’s suggestion we all engage in a little bit of tribal chanting along with her drum, and it’s fun to see what an interactive experience the convention can be.

What actually surprised me was how many fans asked questions that didn’t relate to Supernatural at all. I suppose that’s not surprising for guest stars who haven’t appeared on many episodes, but it was a nice departure. All of the panelists were happy to answer questions that were more of a personal nature, although most fans kept the questions respectful.

While all of the panelists were terrific, you can see which actors are even more outgoing and thrive in this kind of experience. Misha Collins wowed the audience with hilarious stories and a short reading of “Go the F**k to Sleep”, which one fan brought along because Misha reads it to his son. Speight is terrific in a live setting, as is Cohen. Jared and Jensen love playing to the crowd, especially Jared.

Now, for a few spoilers. Honestly, there weren’t a lot given during the convention, but I expected that would be the case. So many fans publicly mourned Castiel’s disappearance from the show and while we all suspect Misha will be returning to Supernatural in its seventh season, he did confirm he won’t be in any episode up to 7.10 (currently, episode 7.09 is shooting – with Guy Bee directing a Ben Edlund script). After their panel, Jared and Jensen returned on stage to auction off a special jar of “Winchester Brothers’ Salt”. Apparently, episode 7.07 will see the brothers engaging in a good old-fashioned hunt that involves laying down salt circles. Ahhhh….the good old days.

Speaking of auctions, the convention auctions are insane. The amount of money people spend on some of the auction items blew my mind. A banner of the Impala sold for over $500, for example. Fortunately, some of the items were auctioned off for charity, which I thought was a terrific idea with a worthy goal.

I brought two friends with me to the convention who had never been to Comic-Con or any other fan conventions. They were thrilled with the overall experience. We didn’t get any photo ops or autograph sessions and limited our experience to the panels and chatting with other fans. But my friends loved the convention and laughed and cheered along with the audience. One of them even asked me “So, should we go again next year?”

For a first-timer, the convention experience was a great one and one that I hope to have again. You can view photos of some of the actors by clicking the arrows above.

Fans who have never been to a Supernatural convention before should definitely attend at least once. I think you might be pleasantly surprised by how much fun you have. And you never know, you may walk away with a prize at the Supernatural trivia contest like I did!

  • Jessica

    Supernatual Cons really are like nothing else. And it's not just the actors. It's the other fans. The first con I attended was in LA back in February, and let me tell you, the awesomeness of it still hasn't worn off. I had a great time and I met some folks there with whom I have become good friends. Sounds like you had a great time and if you do go again, I highly recommend getting photo ops and meet and greets. Especially with Jared and Jensen. They are absolute sweethearts and seem genuinely excited to meet/hang out with fans.

    • Clarissa

      To be honest with you, Jessica, it feels kind of weird for me to be getting photo-ops for the actors seeing as I've met and interviewed them in a professional capacity. But yes, I had a terrific time interacting with the other fans and just watching the panels :)

  • AmyinSydney

    Glad you had a great time Clarissa! But be warned, cons are addictive! I did my first con in Sydney last year which was a small warm up for the big schbang in LA in February. I can honestly say the LACon experience was the most fun I've ever had! All the guests were brilliant and the cast so gracious with their time and energy. I was also impressed with the level of respect the majority of the fans showed both the guests and each other. I met some truly wonderful people, some o whom are now close friends. I've decided to spend my holidays over the next 12 months going to conventions. First up is Chicago in less than 2 weeks. This gives me the opportunity to hangout with my LA buds again as well as a close friend from St Louis whom I met through the fandom. Last year we holidayed in Vegas together! I booked LA again for March, just nipping over the Pacific for a few days for the con and maybe a bit of work and in May some of the cast is coming down under (Weee I can drive to that), but I'm most excited for Vancouver next August. The mother of all conventions. I'm planning 2 weeks for that so I can also sight see. So, yep, I'm addicted. It's equal parts seeing my favorite cast talk about my favorite show and hanging out with great like-minded people. Maybe we'll even get to meet at one one day? Glad you had a great time!

  • Elizabeth B.

    In Sept, PBS ran a show featuring Atlanta convention. It didnt focus on tv or movies. The costumers and steam comics were so dedicated to the art. A convention is on my Places to visit list.

  • @Scyllaya

    The walking in the crowd thing is totally a Richard Speight, Jr. trademark hihi. I'm happy to hear that Matt is doing it too now, even when he's not paired up with Richard in a panel. :) Good habits are spreading fine x)

    Nice article, thanks for sharing :)

  • caitlin

    Wow! Sounds fun! Personally I have never been to a con but I am going to one in Los Vegas pretty soon. I’m bringing one of my friends along and I hope she likes it too! Personally I am a bit worried it won’t be as good as I thought, but from what you said I hope that’s not true and that it will be amazing. I purchased some photo ops and autographs so I think I will enjoy that. Anymore feedback from other people who have attended one would be great! But I am very excited and I don’t believe I will be disappointed. :)

That Guy Actor of the Week: Adam Baldwin
Five Must-See Anime Series You Can Stream on Netflix
Did you Know There were This Many Power Rangers Shows?
Scandal Episode 10: Olivia Pope Talks Female Presidency (SPOILER)
The 1983 HBO Movie Intro Will Now Be in Your Head for Eternity
20 Memorable Green Characters from TV, Movies, and Video Games
15 Actors With Incredible Speaking Voices
korie robertson
Find Out Why Korie Robertson Had A Fan Club of Her Own at Only 7
10 of Our Favorite Geniuses in Movies
Ranking the Films By Guillermo del Toro
Memento’s Brilliant, Beautiful Timeline
Six Disney Characters You Never Knew Existed
German Artist Combines Famous Album Covers With Marvel Characters
Seven Live Performances By U2 That Absolutely Rocked
fall on stage
It Happens to Everyone: When Famous Musicians Fall on Stage
Lady Pank
Obscure 80s Music Videos That Are Extremely 80s
Seven Incredibly Dangerous Car Accidents in NASCAR History
Ever Wonder Why Peyton Manning Says Omaha All The Time?
Don’t Forget to Watch The NFL Honors 2016 Show
Josh Norman
When Is the Official Super Bowl Kick Off of 2016?

Get more stuff like this
in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox.