New Girl Season 6 Episode 16 Review: “Operation: Bobcat”

New Girl Season 6 Episode 16

When it comes to holiday episodes, New Girl has a pretty terrific track record with very few clunkers and a couple of all-time classics that easily go down as some of the best half hours in the show’s history, and while “Operation: Bobcat” may not go into the New Girl Hall of Fame, it’s definitely more of the latter than the former. This installment finds a way to give pretty much every member of the loft (aside from maybe Nick) an emotionally satisfying story, from Winston’s proposal to Aly to Schmidt and Cece celebrating their “bone-iversary.” However, perhaps the best storyline of the episode involves Jess, who after being beaten down and frequently unrecognizable for most of Season 6 rediscovers her strength and finally allows herself to let out her real feelings.

For most of “Operation: Bobcat,” the show’s characters can’t keep from commenting on just how sad Jess seems during Valentine’s Day. She’s the only person in the loft who doesn’t have a significant other to spend it with, and she’s also forced to watch Nick finally step up and be a great boyfriend for Reagan, the type of boyfriend that she feels like Nick never was when the two of them were dating. Winston even goes as far as to call off his proposal to Aly because he feels so bad for Jess, and he wants her to focus on herself this Valentine’s Day instead of worrying about another couple.

It’s here, after Winston’s comments, where Jess begins to let her emotions free, thanks to prompting from Gordon Ramsay, who cooks Jess dinner as part of a contest she won. In a simultaneously cathartic and hilarious scene, Jess reveals that she’s not sad–she’s angry. She’s angry about Nick’s behavior, about how he was never this good of a boyfriend to her when they were together and that Reagan gets to enjoy his maturity now while all she can do is watch. She’s also angry about all of her friends just presuming that she’s sad; whether it’s Schmidt or Cece or even Winston, they all just assume they know what’s going on inside of Jess’s mind without ever asking her, and they pity her instead of respecting her. By unleashing all of her true feelings to not only Gordon Ramsay but more importantly herself, and by forcing Winston to accept her help, Jess ensures that she will no longer be pitied, that she will stand up, be heard, and do what she wants to do, no matter what anyone else thinks. And since Jess has had such an identity crisis throughout so much of New Girl Season 6, mostly due to her relationship with Robby, it’s a powerful moment, even if none of her roommates are around to see it.

After Jess’s proclamation of anger, she helps Winston with his proposal plan for Aly, which he’s forced to accelerate after she casually mentions that they should get married when he stops by her apartment for a surprise Valentine’s Day visit. Winston is so surprised that he actually says “no” to Aly’s impromptu proposal, and he and Jess spend most of “Operation: Bobcat” chopping his 21-stage plan into a one-stage plan, as Winston agrees to propose in what he thinks is the most romantic way possible: by dressing as a bobcat in the bus station bathroom where he first realized just how much he loved Aly. It’s a sweet moment when Winston reveals just how important the titular Operation: Bobcat is to his proposal plan, and the fact that it includes him wearing a costume (one that he’s already purchased before even buying a ring) totally fits in with Winston’s extremely weird but incredibly lovable personality.

Of course, since New Girl is a sitcom, Winston and Jess’s plan doesn’t completely work, as Aly hits Winston, giving him a concussion, when he pops out of the bathroom stall dressed as the bobcat (she’s unsure of what animal he is at first). However, with the assistance of Jess and a police-themed choir, Winston is still able to pull off a pretty sensational proposal, one that is just as odd and wonderful as his relationship with Aly is. When she says yes to becoming his partner for life, it’s genuinely touching, nearly reaching the emotional heights of Schmidt and Cece’s engagement, which is quite impressive given that Schmidt and Cece’s romance had been going on for four years while Winston and Aly have hardly been together for one full season of New Girl. Maybe it’s just me, but I love these crazy kids together.

And speaking of Schmidt and Cece, “Operation: Bobcat” also provides the newlyweds with a solid story of their own, as they struggle with being separated from one another during their first Valentine’s Day as a married couple. Plus, since Valentine’s Day is also the anniversary of when the two of them first slept together all the way back in Season 1 (an anniversary that Schmidt refers to as their “bone-iversary”), the holiday holds even more significance for them than most couples, which is why Cece decides it’s her turn to do something special for Schmidt and sets up a lovely spot for them on the roof of his work so they can celebrate.

Of course, Schmidt and Cece run into trouble from Schmidt’s boss, Kim, who he has been desperately trying to impress so that he can get a promotion, but when it comes down to choosing between his job and his wife, Schmidt picks Cece and tells Kim straight to her face that work will never be as important as the love he has for her. It’s another sweet moment for Schmidt and Cece, one that proves yet again that New Girl has only benefited from them getting together at the end of Season 4 and marrying at the end of Season 5. Will-they-won’t-they relationships are only entertaining for so long, and the New Girl writers have been able to create stronger material for Schmidt and Cece since their engagement, giving them all-new sets of problems that bring them closer together rather than pushing them apart.

“Operation: Bobcat” allows most of New Girl‘s main characters (Nick has some funny moments throughout the episode, but he mostly just wanders from storyline to storyline, talking about his and Reagan’s gifts for each other) to have standout moments, whether they’re as a couple, such as Schmidt and Cece, or as an individual, like Jess. It’s not my favorite Valentine’s Day episode of New Girl (I think I’d still have to give that title to Season 4’s “The Crawl”), but it certainly stands as one Season 6’s best half hours and serves as a reminder of just how good this series is at celebrating the holidays.

Other thoughts:

  • Nick doesn’t seem too happy with Reagan’s Valentine’s Day gift for him, which is a necklace (or a chain, as Jess suggests). Between that and the problems they had last week, I’m giving Nick and Reagan three more episodes before they break up. I just can’t see Season 6 ending with the two of them still together.
  • After meeting Tevlo, I want him to be in every episode of New Girl. Or maybe we can get some type of web spin-off series about him and his shady dealings? “Stay blessed.”
  • Nick bringing Schmidt his college graduation suit (which looks to be about five sizes too big) and Cece’s wedding dress so that they can change is the most “Nick Miller” moment of the episode.
  • I’m still grinning over the fact that Winston and Aly are actually engaged.
  • This episode does a nice job of giving Schmidt’s boss, Kim, some real humanity, and I love the fact that she grants Schmidt the promotion not just because of his work ethic but because of his honesty when he tells her that Cece will always be more important than his job.
  • Jess calls Winston “America’s sweetheart” and also describes him in the most perfect way possible: “You really toe the line between sweetness and insanity.”
  • “I feel five feet tall.” “You’re taller than five feet right now.”
  • “Say what you want, but that woman can shuffle.”
  • “How long have we been waiting for this elevator? What are we in the lobby of Sterling Cooper?”

What did everyone else think about this week’s episode of New Girl? Comment below and let me know.

[Photo credit: Ray Mickshaw/FOX]

New Girl Season 6 Episode 16 Review: "Operation: Bobcat"
4.5

Summary

Jess helps Winston come up with the perfect proposal for Aly in New Girl‘s fantastic Valentine’s Day episode.

Sending
User Review
1 (1 vote)



Add Comment

What We Learned from the First Official Trailer for WandaVision
Pennyworth Season 2 Teases Biggest Batman Connection So Far
Five Actresses Who Should Play Silk in the Live-Action Marvel Show
A Venture Bros. Season 8 May Very Well Happen on HBO Max
Gandalf
Why Gandalf The Grey/White Is The Greatest Movie Mentor Ever
The Five Best Mystery Thriller Movies of the 80s
Is It Possible We’ll See a Sequel to Napoleon Dynamite?
A Young Mace Windu Standalone Project Reportedly in Development
Has Paris Hilton Been Faking The Dumb Blonde Thing This Whole Time?
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Ray Panthaki
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Mark Ivanir
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Mallory Santic
Elm Street
Did You Know Marvel Made a Freddy Kreuger Comic in 1989?
Five Reasons Why DeSaad Deserves a Solo Movie
What We Learned from The Batman: Three Jokers Trailer
The One DC Character Who Can’t Stand His Own Super Powers
The Top Ten Dueling Monsters In Yu-Gi-Oh!
The Top Five Yu-Gi-Oh! Villains
Vinland Saga
Why You Should Be Watching Vinland Saga
Super Anime
Check Out Mario & Luigi: Super Anime Brothers
Thirty Minutes of Rain From Thirty Different Video Games
Someone Managed to Get Doom to Run on a Digital Pregnancy Test
Mario Kart Live: Home Circuit Transforms Living Room Into A Mario Kart Level
This is The Battery-Free Gameboy That Can Run Forever