The Man in the High Castle: Pilot Review

The Man in the High Castle

The Man in the High Castle marks a new direction for Amazon’s original offerings in 2015, one of the show’s first genuine attempts at high-stakes, hour-long drama (following the ignored Hysteria and the recently-cancelled The After), and a show that neatly falls into line with modern trends of American television. Adaptation of literature? Check. CGI backdrops that scream “prestige show”? Check. All sorts of intrigue, mystery, and a slight tinge of the supernatural? Check. (and for a bonus: Nazi drama? Big check).

And yet depsite all that, The Man in the High Castle is actually pretty good.

Adapted from Phillip K. Dick’s novel of the same name, The Man in the High Castle is set in an alternate world, where the U.S. lost World War II, and the Germans and Japanese split the United States into two (with a small buffer “peace zone” set across the Rocky Mountains). Taking place in 1962, it examines the growing tension in the extended Reich on the East Coast and the Japanese Pacific States out west; more importantly, it takes place right as Adolf Hitler is succumbing to illness, putting the world on edge of war once again. One part The Americans, one part Lost (we’ll get to that), and two parts generic period drama, The Man in the High Castle is most fascinating when its building out its world, displaying an America crushed and split into two, living under the thumbs of two powerful, yet distinct regimes.

At that, The Man in the High Castle is one of the most intriguing pilots in recent memory, an unsettling dystopia that is so fascinating and well-constructed, it overshadows any attempt at the pilot to deepen its characters. While there’s certainly an ensemble to the show, the only characters the pilot distinctly focuses on are the two newest to the underground resistance being formed around a secret newsreel showing a world where the US did win World War II: Joe Blake, a newly-minted rebel driving from NY to Colorado with a special package, and Juliana Crain, a woman who heads to Colorado in place of her sister when she’s murdered by Japanese police. However, the pilot doesn’t do a lot to make them interesting characters; instead, they acts as conduits of silent exposition into this new world, which robs the script of some of its more intriguing, shadowed exploration of identity, allegiance – and at its core, reality.

It’s not that Luke Kleintank or Alexa Davalos don’t try to bring nuance to their characters; they do (particularly Davalos), there’s just not a lot of detail spared for character, as it tries to set up this ambitious, expansive story of an alternate world. And when The Man in the High Castle begins to tug at the strings of that world, it gets a lot more interesting: as people wonder (including DJ Squalls, who appears in a recurring role) what is happening to the Fuhrer, everyone is scrambling to prepare for war – and all the espionage, double-crossing, and assassinating that comes along with it, which appears to lay out an intricate web of deception and mystery as each character continuously questions themselves and others, forming alliances that seemingly go against the uniforms they wear, or roles they play in society.

When The Man in the High Castle dips into that duality, that exploration of perception, it really begins to come together, truly beginning to reach at that Dickian exploration of reality. The news reel Juliana watches isn’t just some random collection of images that could’ve been; that news reel is full of information from a world familiar to the audience, twisting what initially appeared to be a fantasy series with a spy angle, to an existential exploration of reality. What does it mean to be ‘free’? What is ‘victory’ really anyway? Are there infinite realities? These are the questions The Man in the High Castle seems to be interested in; so interested, in fact, it comes at the cost of its characters.

Despite that, The Man in the High Castle’s pilot is very good at… well, being a pilot. Should (and they should) Amazon order this to series, a full season order will give the writers plenty of time to flesh out the people living in the vibrant dystopian world they’ve constructed with this pilot. With The Man in the High Castle, Amazon has their first promising dramatic series; let’s hope they see this one through to a full season, exuding a confidence not yet seen in their potential hour-long offerings.

[Photo via Amazon]

Add Comment

Supersize My Pool
10 Things You Didn’t Know About Supersize My Pool
Edward Furlong is Back for Terminator: Dark Fate
CW Pandora
Meet the Cast of The CW’s “Pandora”
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Secrets of the Dead
Gabrielle Union Breaking In
The Five Best Gabrielle Union Movies of Her Career
After Watching the New ‘Cats’ Trailer, I Now Know What Hell Looks Like
What We Know So Far About The Jay and Silent Bob Reboot
Super Size Me 2
Five Things We Learned from the Super Size Me 2 Trailer
Everything the Light Touches: Ranking the Movies of the Disney Renaissance
Kevin Spacey’s Life is Going To Suck From Now On, Period
Godzilla is Officially on Twitter and Instagram Now
jessica hayes
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Jessica Hayes
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Ironheart
Marvel vs. DC
Study Shows That DC is More Popular Than Marvel
Stan Lee Book ‘A Trick of the Light’ Coming Soon
10 Things You Never Knew about Hellcat
Golden Kamuy
Why You Should Be Watching Golden Kamuy
The Quintessential Quintuplets
Why You Should be Watching The Quintessential Quintuplets
Neon Genesis Evangelion
Why You Should be Watching Neon Genesis Evangelion
Kashin Koji
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Kashin Koji
Sega Genesis Mini
We Cannot Wait to Play on the Sega Genesis Mini
LEGO Star Wars Skywalker Saga
LEGO’s The Skywalker Saga Video Game Looks Amazing
Cyberpunk 2077
Why Cyberpunk 2077 Could be a Game Changer
E3 2019
The Best and Worst of E3 2019